web analytics
Tuesday, March 28, 2023
No Result
View All Result
Budapest Reporter
  • industry
  • reviews
  • production
  • interviews
  • Find Your Partner
  • industry
  • reviews
  • production
  • interviews
  • Find Your Partner
No Result
View All Result
Budapest Reporter
No Result
View All Result

The Wrought Landscape of LGBTQ+ Cinema in Hollywood and Beyond

Leo Barton by Leo Barton
2021-02-09
in filming, industry
Reading Time: 6 mins read
The Wrought Landscape of LGBTQ+ Cinema in Hollywood and Beyond

The Wrought Landscape of LGBTQ+ Cinema in Hollywood and Beyond

ADVERTISEMENT

While LGBTQ+ and transgender individuals have always contributed greatly to independent and avant-garde art scenes, throughout the early 21st century we have seen tectonic shifts ushering in an entirely new space for such communities in the mainstream. While this has occurred across the board, for this article let’s keep our lens focused on popular film and television.

While LGBTQ+ and transgender individuals have always contributed greatly to independent and avant-garde art scenes, throughout the early 21st century we have seen tectonic shifts ushering in an entirely new space for such communities in the mainstream. While this has occurred across the board, for this article let’s keep our lens focused on popular film and television.

Even just within the last few years, we have seen giants like Disney introducing characters with various identities, long-standing series like “Star Trek: Discovery” carving out space for non-binary and transgender characters and platforms as colossal as Netflix giving much needed exhibition space explorations of identity. The most recent of which, “Disclosure: Trans Lives on Screen”, providing a probing look behind the curtain.

However, to look at this progression and to call these issues resolved would be to miss the point. As although the ideology of embracing all identities may be moving through Hollywood like a wildfire, that is not to say there are not concerns to be flagged up both in the US and abroad.

Residual Representations

In 1985, Alison Bechdel drew up a now iconic comic strip in her series titled “Dykes to Watch Out For”. The strip, itself titled The Rule lay out the foundations of what would become the Bechdel test—a measure to identify male-centric female characters through cinema. To pass the test a film would need to (1) have at least two women in it, (2) who talk to each other, (3) about something other than a man.

Although the test is obviously misunderstood as identifying feminist films—which is does not necessarily do—the incredibly overwhelming failure of Hollywood films to include these three simple factors was a stark measure of Hollywood’s warped representation of women.

Taking inspiration from the Bechdel test, GLAAD co-founder Vito Russo penned the Vito Russo test to shine a light on LGBTQ+ representation. Here for films needed to (1) contain a character that identifies as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or queer, (2) who does not solely define themselves by their sexual orientation while (3) being tied into the plot in such a way that their removal would have a significant effect.

While such a metric may be doomed to fail in today’s industry en masse, the test found only 64% of LGBTQ-inclusive studio films passed the test themselves. While such a result could be read in a number of ways, it’s clear that the crux of LGBTQ+ representation is yet to reach its conclusion.

However, we cannot ignore the overwhelming increase in inclusion. GLAAD noted in 2018 that 18.2% of all major studio releases included LGBTQ+ characters. Similarly, 8.8% of all regular characters in primetime scripted broadcast TV shows aired between 2018 and 2019 identified as LGBTQ, setting a new yearly record.

But Lumping all identities into the easy to classify label of LGBTQ+ also has its problems. The numbers above may suggest an overwhelming push for all identities, but this is clearly not the case. Laverne Cox, the transgender actress and activist, stated in an interview with Variety that there are particularly few transgender actors in film; explaining “many studio executives privately admit they are worried that casting gay or transgender actors could hurt the bottom line of a film in international territories — especially China — that are less tolerant of LGBTQ+ rights.”

Cox further explains that this reluctance for inclusion becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy similar to that of Hollywood’s prior reluctance to cast those of non-white races—a notion torn apart by the recent international success of films like Black Panther among many others.

A Global Concern

It goes without saying that LGBTQ+ rights and representation are a concern that stretches far beyond Hollywood and the US. However, as per Cox’s aforementioned comments, it is not often seen this way by the American industry. With studio films and executives pandering to the needs of international market censorship standards, these representations often get side-lined, damaged or cut altogether.

To cite a well-known example, at the climax of “Star Wars The Rise of Skywalker”, as the rebels celebrate their victory, two female rebels share a joyful kiss. While this marked the first show of same-sex affection within the, then, 42 year old series it also sparked much debate when the moment was cut from the Singaporean release.

Similar cuts, exclusions or creative wariness can be seen when exporting American films across the globe. Be it in the second largest market, China, where every released film must first be approved by censors or in smaller nations like Singapore and the UAE among countless others. While some territories, like Russia, have rife anti-gay legislation the issue often seems to transcend legal boundaries being passed on a case-by-case basis which often places transgender representations and male homosexuality at the bottom of the barrel.

But, in my opinion, some of the issues regarding the US export of LGBTQ+ acceptance through media taps into a larger disconnect between the USA and its historical and political opponents. Resulting a similar reaction in such nations to when historically communist ideals are introduced or suggested to take seed within the US system. In short, few competitors will ever want to bow down to the ideology of an opponent—regardless of whether it is right or not.

Outside of the world of film, throughout the early 2010s the American government embarked on an ambitious campaign to expand rights for the LGBTQ+ community across the globe. While over $700 million was earmarked for such support, many of the nations who received the US’s moralistic finger-point exclaimed that such outside influence didn’t help the situation.

One example from Nigeria, who reported to the New York Times, explained that “The U.S. support is making matters worse… There’s more resistance now. It’s triggered people’s defence mechanism.” Of course, such teething issues are inevitable with any social change—however these responses may suggest such an approach is not ideal.

Supernova (2020)

“It’s rare to see a cinematic drama executed with such consistent care as Supernova, written and directed by Harry Macqueen and starring Colin Firth and Stanley Tucci. And here, that care pays off to devastating effect.” – New York Times

Behind the Camera

While representations continue to change in front of the camera, it is in the interest of many to ensure that such changes are reflected in the creative crew working behind the scenes.

Again, inspired by Bechdel, there have been several tests suggested to help raise awareness of the ongoing gender and representational imbalances within film crews. The Uphold Test simply asks whether 50% of the crew are female, while the Waithe test investigates the inclusion of African Americans working behind the camera.

To my knowledge, there are yet to be any widespread tests exploring LGBTQ+ representation within film crews.

Through this all, it is clear that Hollywood and the global film industry is shifting towards accepting LGBTQ+ representation—with different nations moving at expectedly different paces. Yet many claim even the US’s approach is “the bare minimum” for an array of reasons. Foremost of which may be the fact that some of the newfound representations may be somewhat disingenuous, given the fact that queer people, especially white queer people, are a significant marketing demographic. This makes simply catering to those communities (without engaging in the ideological discourse) a favourable approach to many within a capitalist system.

That said, with the ever strengthening presence of pragmatic and theoretical institutions, from GLAAD to the Annenberg Inclusion Initiative, it is clear that those fighting for representation form the true backbone of LGBTQ+ representations in cinema, not the Hollywood Studios.

Tags: Colettefilm industryglaadLGBTQ+representationSupernovatransgender

More like this

Int’l Quorum of Motion Picture Producers to Meet in Budapest This Year
industry

Int’l Quorum of Motion Picture Producers to Meet in Budapest This Year

2023-03-16
Above Below The Line – Interview with Andrew Toth
interview

Above Below The Line – Interview with Andrew Toth

2023-02-24
The Last of Us Episode 3 – Analyzing the Controversy Behind HBO's New Show
featured

The Last of Us Episode 3 – Analyzing the Controversy Behind HBO’s New Show

2023-02-22
Virtual Production - The New Challenger Within The Film Industry
industry

Virtual Production – The New Challenger Within The Film Industry

2022-09-12
A Round-up of Last Week's Events: 8 August - 12 August 2022
featured

A Round-up of Last Week’s Events: 8 August – 12 August 2022

2022-08-17
A round-up of the last week's events: 20 - 24 June 2022
featured

A round-up of the last week’s events: 20 – 24 June 2022

2022-06-27
Load More

Latest news

The Box Office Failure of Shazam! Fury of the Gods Highlights the Risk of Superhero Fatigue
featured

The Box Office Failure of Shazam! Fury of the Gods Highlights the Risk of Superhero Fatigue

2023-03-27
BPR Newsflash - New Projects by Gunn, Del Toro and Tarantino
featured

BPR Newsflash – New Projects by Gunn, Del Toro and Tarantino

2023-03-23
DIGIC - The Next Chapter
interview

DIGIC – The Next Chapter

2023-03-21
Hungarian Oscar Dinner to Celebrate Past and Present Accomplishments
featured

Hungarian Oscar Dinner to Celebrate Past and Present Accomplishments

2023-03-18
Medium Voltage - Shazam! Fury of the Gods Review
review

Medium Voltage – Shazam! Fury of the Gods Review

2023-03-16
Origo Studios Successfully Scales Up Post-Prod Environment
industry

Origo Studios Successfully Scales Up Post-Prod Environment

2023-03-14
ADVERTISEMENT
Budapest Reporter

© 2022 BPR Publishing

Navigate Site

  • Impressum
  • Advertisement
  • Business Directory
  • Privacy and Data Protection

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Industry
  • Review
  • Production
  • Interview
  • Gossip

© 2022 BPR Publishing